- Reviewed on: 19 June 2018
The best all-round Fitbit
The Fitbit Charge 2 has just about every fitness-tracking feature that the top-end Fitbits boast, in a slim, lightweight band. It measures steps, distance, active minutes, floors climbed, calories burned, heart rate, sleep stages, and cardio-fitness levels, plus boasts automatic multi-sports tracking.
It also offers super-useful on-wrist notifications such as Caller ID, texts and calendar alerts, and can connect to your phone’s GPS for runs. It might not have all the apps you get with the Versa and Ionic but its feature set really is near complete.
As such it represents great value for money, and is available in seven colours - the biggest choice of all the Fitbits.
Fitbit has also announced a new model, to go on sale in October; read our Fitbit Charge 3 review for more details.
Read our Fitbit Charge 2 review.
2. Fitbit Versa
- Reviewed on: 6 August 2018
The best Fitbit smartwatch
While it lacks the built-in GPS of the Ionic, the Fitbit Versa is otherwise identical in features, and is smaller and lighter on the wrist. And, of course, it can still connect with the GPS on your phone. As a smartwatch it can use a growing number of apps (Weather, Starbucks, Runkeeper, Strava and more) as well as on-wrist Fitbit Pay and music storage and control, plus notifications such as Caller ID and texts.
Fitbit Coach offers animated on-screen workouts. It also boasts more designer accessories than the Ionic. While aimed at women (who might find the Ionic too large) the Versa is most definitely a unisex design – although it would take a confident man to wear the Peach/Rose-Gold version.
Read our Fitbit Versa review.
- Reviewed on: 10 July 2017
The best Fitbit for beginners
The Fitbit Flex 2 is the slimmest, lightest and (let’s face it) least expensive Fitbit wristband. It has a minimalist display of four dots, and (like the Fitbit Versa and Ionic) can track your swimming stats. It doesn’t boast all the features found on others (there’s no altimeter for measuring floors climbed, heart-rate monitor, clock or multi-sports tracking) but if you’re mainly interested in entry-level fitness metrics such as steps, distance and calories, the Flex 2 is a great start for activity tracking.
Via extra accessories, you can also wear it as a fashionable bangle or pendant. But if you want a clock and smart notifications you’ll need to spend a little more.
Read our Fitbit Flex 2 review.
4. Fitbit Ionic
- Reviewed on: 11 May 2018
The best Fitbit for sports
The Fitbit Ionic is the most fully featured Fitbit smartwatch and activity tracker. It has it all, and its built-in GPS is great for runners or exercisers who don’t want to lug their phone around with them.
As well as all the usual fitness stats it features automatic multi-sports tracking, Fitbit Coach for on-screen workouts, Caller ID and texts notifications on wrist, can store up to 300 songs with music control and be used for contactless payments, as well as chose from a range of special apps (Weather, Starbucks, Runkeeper, Strava, and more).
The Fitbit Versa (which has the same features minus the built-in GPS) is cheaper and smaller, but the Ionic is still lightweight enough for you not to realise you’re wearing it.
Read our Fitbit Ionic review.
- Reviewed on: 31 May 2018
The best Fitbit for fashion
While in no way restricted to women, the slim, chic and stylish Fitbit Alta HR has the largest selection of wristbands and other fashionable accessories. It’s also a very able activity tracker – measuring steps, distance, active minutes, calories burned, heart rate, sleep stages, and cardio-fitness levels.
Its heart-rate monitor means you’ll get deeper insights into your exercise and sleep monitoring, and so is worth the extra £30/$20 on the less-able Fitbit Alta. We also prefer its watch-type buckle to the pop-clasp of the Alta.
Read our Fitbit Alta HR review.
6. Fitbit Ace
- Reviewed on: 2 July 2018
The best Fitbit for kids
Until recently children under 13 were not allowed to have a personal Fitbit account. Now the minimum age is 8 – as long as you use the Fitbit Ace, which measures Steps, Distance and Active Time, plus basic sleep monitoring. Special family account features mean kids (and parents) can track their basic activity stats through a secure Kid View, where they can see their progress, compete in challenges, and earn badges.
The Ace is about exercise not just weight loss – Fitbit hides the calorie counter to stop children obsessing about their weight. The strap is small but you can add accessories meant for the Fitbit Alta, on which it’s based. Older kids might prefer a Fitbit that does more, such as measure heart rate.
Read our Fitbit Ace review.
7. Fitbit Alta
- Reviewed on: 29 June 2018
The cheapest Fitbit with a proper display
The only great thing we can say about the Fitbit Alta is that it’s £30/$20 cheaper than the equally stylish Fitbit Alta HR. But that price difference does make it appealing, and – despite lacking the HR’s heart-rate monitor and better sleep-quality and cardio-fitness level tracking – the super-slim Alta is a decent fitness tracker with as many fashion accessories as the more able HR.
We do prefer the Alta HR’s watch-type strap buckle, though, so look out for online deals on the HR first.
Read our Fitbit Alta review.
Which Fitbit is best for you?
Here's a brief function summary, before we go into more detail about features, price, battery life and more.
|Ace||Flex 2||Alta||Alta HR||Charge 2||Versa||Ionic|
|Shop at Fitbit||Buy||Buy||Buy||Buy||Buy||Buy||Buy|
|Steps, Calories & Distance||Y||Y||Y||Y||Y||Y||Y|
|Sleep Tracking & Silent Alarm||Y||Y||Y||Y||Y||Y||Y|
|Sleep Stages (Light, Deep, REM)||-||-||-||Y||Y||Y||Y|
|Reminders To Move||Y||Y||Y||Y||Y||Y||Y|
|PurePulse Heart Rate||-||-||-||Y||Y||Y||Y|
|Cardio Fitness Level||-||-||-||Y||Y||Y||Y|
|Call & Text Notifications||Calls||Y||Y||Y||Y||Y||Y|
|Guided Breathing Sessions||-||-||-||-||Y||Y||Y|
Fitbit features compared
The cheap clip-on Zip that we didn't include in our chart lacks the sleep tracking and silent wake alarm found on the other trackers. And it doesn't buzz when you hit your Steps goal. It also doesn't feature a heart-rate monitor, or the sports functions and notification alerts.
For kids below the age of 13, the Ace is a superior starter tracker. It's recommended for children aged 8 up, and there are special Parent and Kid views, plus family challenges and virtual badges to be won. Its strap is smaller than even the Small size options with the other trackers, but we found the other Fitbits to fit a child's wrist just as well.
The Ace can be customised with straps for the Alta and Alta HR. While it's in Fitbit's terms and conditions that children aged under 13 should use only the Ace, there are plenty of kids out there wearing other models - parents just need to set-up the child's account using an older birth year.
The cheapest Fitbit wristband is the Flex 2, but this lacks some features of the more expensive Fitbits, such as an altimeter to measure floors climbed, multi-sport functions, heart rate, Caller ID, text notifications and GPS tracking. But casual users don't really need the heart-rate monitor or sports capabilities, and only the top-end Ionic actually boasts a built-in GPS anyway.
With the Versa and Ionic, the Flex 2 is also one of only three swim-ready Fitbit trackers.
The Alta is one step up from the Flex 2, but quite a jump in terms of price. For the extra money you gain Caller ID and Text Notifications, which many will find very useful. If your phone is a short distance from you but not in your pocket or in Silent mode then that little vibration alert that a call is incoming can be super handy. The Alta is a good deal if the heart monitor and sleep tracking aren't important to you.
If you do jog, run or exercise in any way as well as walking we think that it's worth paying for the extra heart-rate-monitoring functionality you get with the Alta HR, Charge 2, Versa and Ionic. Monitoring heart rate can also be used if weight loss is one of your key goals. But if you're just interested in everyday exercise the Fitbit Flex 2 or Alta will suffice, and are excellent trackers. The heart-rate function also gives you more detailed Sleep analysis - see later on for more details.
We also prefer the watch-buckle strap found on the Alta HR, Charge 2, Versa and Ionic. It feels more secure, and again is worth the paying extra for. If you want a wide range of straps and other accessories the Flex 2 has the most options, including a bangle and pendant, but the Alta, Alta HR and Versa also boast a large array of accessories, and you get plenty of options with the Charge 2 and Ionic.
Remember to factor in the cost of the straps and accessories to the price of the wristband trackers if you fancy something different to the included Classic bands. Having a choice of straps is appreciated, but it does make the pricing harder to compare.
Which Fitbit trackers have certain features?
All Fitbits have an accelerometer that measures motion patterns to determine your calories burned, distance travelled, and steps taken. (The Fitbit Ace does not show calories burned, as Fitbit doesn't want to add to a child's weight anxiety issues.) All but the Zip also monitor sleep quality.
The Flex 2, Ace, Alta, Alta HR, Charge 2, Versa and Ionic also contain a vibration motor, which allows it to vibrate when alarms are set to go off.
The Charge 2, Versa and Ionic boast an altimeter that measures stairs (or height) climbed. Despite its name the Alta does not include an altimeter.
The Fitbit Ionic boasts eight sensors, and is the only model in the lineup to have GPS built in without the need for a smartphone to be linked. Users can see distance, pace and elevation climbed, and review routes and split times. The Charge 2 and Versa can connect to the GPS on your smartphone.
Heart rate monitor
The Alta HR, Charge 2, Versa and Ionic monitor your heart rate on your wrist. They use Fitbit's PurePulse technology that gives continuous, automatic, wrist-based heart rate, plus simplified heart-rate zones.
Additionally the Charge 2, Versa and Ionic feature Cardio Fitness Level, which provides a snapshot of your cardiovascular fitness. Based on estimated VO2 Max – calculated by your user profile, heart rate and exercise data – you can see how your fitness level relates to others of the same age and gender, and get guidance on how to improve over time.
The Versa and Ionic can also monitor the amount of oxygen in the blood (an important health indicator) with their Sp02 sensor.
Caller ID and text messages
The Ace, Charge 2, Alta, Alta HR, Versa and Ionic will all show Caller ID when linked to a smartphone. All the wristbands except the Flex 2 and the Ace also display text notifications on its display, and the Versa and Ionic allow you to control your music from the touchscreen display - each being able to store up to 300 songs on the watch.
Automatic sport recognition
The Alta, Alta HR, Charge 2, Versa and Ionic feature multi-sport exercise tracking. They know when you're cycling, running, hiking or playing sports including football, tennis and basketball. They will also recognise aerobic workouts such as Zumba, cardio-kickboxing and dance workouts, and log the workout in the Fitbit app along with an exercise summary.
Reminder to Move
This is available on all the wristband Fitbit trackers. It encourages you to meet a mini-step goal of 250 steps each hour (approximately 2-3 minutes of walking). These prompts can be personalised to your schedule; for example they can be put on “Do Not Disturb” during long meetings or appointments. And they won't wake you at night.
All the Fitbits, except the Zip, check your sleep, too. They measure the time you spend asleep and check the quality of sleep – noting when you are restless or wake up during the night. Fitbit's new Sleep Stages measurements (on Alta HR, Charge 2, Versa, and Ionic) utilise heart-rate variability to estimate the amount of time you spend in Light, Deep and REM sleep, as well as time awake each night, to better understand your sleep quality.
This is one of the great benefits of a tracker with a heart monitor, and sleep is now recognised as a major health metric.
The Charge 2, Versa and Ionic offer Relax Guided Breathing sessions that can help calm your body and mind through two- and five-minute sessions personalised to your breathing rate. The benefits of guided breathing practice are supposed to help reduce stress and anxiety, as well as lower blood pressure. Add it to your daily routine, and you'll quickly feel the benefits.
Which Fitbit has the best display?
The Zip display has five modes: Steps; Distance; Calories burned; Fitbit Smiley (highlights your recent activity level); and Clock.
The Flex 2’s display is the most minimal, consisting of a series of flashing dots that show you how your day is stacking up against your goals. Each light represents 20 percent of your goal. You just tap the display twice to see your progress against your daily goal.
The Fitbit Alta and Alta HR take a longer, vertical view of its displays, and show much more information than the Flex 2.
The Fitbit Ace shows the same stats as the Alta, minus Calories Burned.
The Charge 2's OLED display (below) shows Time; Steps; Heart Rate; Distance; Calories burned; Floors climbed; Very active minutes; Caller ID; Text Notification; and Alarm.
The Versa's colourful touchscreen display is even better for visual display of fitness stats.
The Ionic's larger display (below) shows even more data to fitness and sports nuts. Like the Versa, its display is a touchscreen colour LCD. You can choose from 17 different clock faces, and watch (and listen to) guided exercise workout training sessions.
Which Fitbit has the best battery life?
The Zip is easily the best for battery life but you will need to buy a new battery two or three times a year. The 3V coin (CR 2025) battery is cheap, though – you can buy a pack of five for under £2.50 (US$3). The other models have rechargeable batteries. Here's roughly how long each lasts between charges:
Zip: 4-6 months
Flex 2: up to 5 days
Ace: up to 5 days
Alta: up to 5 days
Alta HR: up to 7 days
Charge 2: Up to 5 days
Versa: up to 4 days
Ionic: Up to 5 days (will reduce depending on use of GPS)
Which Fitbits are water resistant?
The Flex 2, Versa and Ionic trackers are officially sanctioned as waterproof (down to 50M), and have basic swimming tracking features (number of lengths, distance swam). Experts recommend that you don't wear it while bathing, snorkelling or scuba diving, and Fitbit calls them water resistant rather than properly waterproof. (Note that accessory straps on the Versa and Ionic might not all be waterproof.)
The Zip is just splash proof, while the Alta, Alta HR and Charge 2 are water resistant to 1 ATM (Atmosphere), so theoretically can be submerged up to 10 metres (33ft).
Do all Fitbits use the same app?
Yes. They all use the same iPhone, Android and Windows Phone apps.
The app displays all your daily and historical stats in beautiful graphs that expand in landscape orientation as well as display in portrait view. It's here that Fitbit really beats its activity-tracking rivals.
The desktop dashboard is another visually attractive and informative place to monitor your activity and fitness statistics.
And as an incentive you can link with friends, family and colleagues to compete against each other on the leaderboard, get involved in daily or weekly Challenges and Adventures, and win badges determined by passing goals, and historical milestones. These aspects of the Fitbit system really set it apart from the other trackers.